The 96th Academy Awards may have wrapped, but the real party was just getting started at the Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts. Celebrating its 30th anniversary, the annual Vanity Fair Oscar after-party lived up to its reputation as a star-studded extravaganza.

The night was a red carpet runway with a twist — a nod to the party’s milestone year. Think classic Hollywood glamour with a healthy dose of contemporary glitz. From Margot Robbie’s Mugler moment to Vanessa Hudgens’ pregnancy announcement in sheer Alberta Ferretti, the fashion parade was a feast for the eyes (and cameras).

But who doesn’t love a good celeb candid moment?! Lucky for us, amidst the designer duds and A-list mingling, a more relatable trend emerged: the humble In-N-Out burger.

Irina Shayk, Emily Ratajkowski, and Adwoa Aboah were spotted huddled together with their In-N-Out delicacies in hand. The likes of Ashley Graham, Lindsay Lohan, and Ciara couldn’t resist the siren song of a juicy burger either, with Graham caught mid-bite on camera (#mood). Even Steven Spielberg indulged in the night with In-N-Out, taking his own personal pics of his prized possession burger — which is living rent-free in our head tbh.

This unexpected culinary cameo speaks volumes about the enduring appeal of this West Coast staple — and goes to show that even our favorite celebrities are just as much human as the rest of us.

In a world of celebrity excess, it’s a reminder that even the most glamorous stars crave the simple pleasures. Perhaps it’s the nostalgic taste of childhood, or maybe it’s just a damn good burger. Whatever the reason, In-N-Out undeniably stole the show, proving that sometimes, the most unforgettable moments come wrapped in a paper wrapper.

PHOTOS: Vanity Fair Oscar Party Feat. Celebrities & Their Coveted In-N-Out Burgers